A Rs 50,000 payment dispute in Kanpur, suspected forged transplant documents in Kerala and a Bangladesh-linked investigation in Delhi have raised questions about donor protection, hospital approvals and the enforcement of India's organ transplantation laws.
In May 2026, Kerala Police received a tip about suspected illegal organ transplantation activities happening in Pothanamparambu, Ernakulam. Following the tip-off, the police raided a rented house on the morning of 7th May 2026, which reportedly led to the recovery of forged official seals, letterheads, identity documents and at least 20 files linked to organ transplantation applications submitted before the District Authorisation Committee.
In a Kerala High Court order dated 11th August 2026, it was noted that the police obtained the original files from the committee which were compared with the documents recovered during the raid. Furthermore, kidney donors, recipients and government officials whose names appeared on the certificates were questioned during the investigation. According to the police, they found records containing forged signatures and seals. Some of the documents appeared to have been altered to establish relationships between the donors and recipients that did not exist.
The main accused in the case was Muhammed Najeeb Kallatra. Police stated that during the investigation, they recorded the statement of one of the donors, identified as KM Radhakrishnan. He reportedly told the police that he had agreed to donate a kidney to a recipient identified as Surendra and received Rs 6.75 lakh for the donation in his sister’s bank account. The amount was transferred before the surgery. Another witness, identified as Maya, who was presented as Surendra’s sister, reportedly informed the investigating officials that she had met the recipient for the first time at a hospital. She stated that the documents had been prepared to establish a false family relationship.
According to available documents linked to the case, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) also initiated an investigation in the matter. Raids were conducted on 18th June 2026 at nine premises. On 21st June, ED issued a press release stating that they uncovered a network operating through Kallatharas Medical Tourism Pvt Ltd which targeted financially distressed individuals and offered them money for donating kidneys. The compensation for illegal donation ranged from Rs 5 lakh to Rs 15 lakh depending on the case. On the other hand, the recipients were charged anywhere between Rs 20 lakh to Rs 35 lakh or even more for the transplantation.
ED, Kochi Zonal Office, has conducted search operations on 18.06.2026 at 09 premises in Kerala under the provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), 2002, in connection with the large-scale illegal organ trafficking racket across Kerala. During the search operations, various incriminating records, details of immovable properties held in the name of the accused persons and their associates and digital evidence were seized. Further, freezing orders have also been issued in respect of the bank accounts of agents and intermediaries who facilitated the illegal organ trade.
During the hearing at the Kerala High Court, Najeeb continued to deny the allegations against him. He claimed that he was falsely implicated in the case. However, the court refused him bail on 11th August 2026 after examining the police records and prosecution material. In its order, the court stated that there was sufficient evidence at the preliminary stage to justify continued custody.
Indian law permits living organ donation, but under specified conditions and strict rules. The law is in place to curb commercial dealings in human organs. According to the law established by the Government of India, a person may voluntarily donate a kidney to an eligible relative or, subject to additional approval, to someone outside the family. The hospitals conducting transplantations are required to obtain the necessary permissions, donors are required to undergo medical evaluation, and certain applications need independent scrutiny before the operation can happen.
However, the illegal donation racket busted in Kerala is not an isolated case that raised questions about the circumstances surrounding organ transplantations happening in the country. For instance, in April 2026, a rather curious case surfaced in Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh, where a dispute over Rs 50,000 led police towards a network involving private hospitals and medical professionals allegedly involved in illegal organ trade. Similarly, in 2024, in Delhi, investigators busted an illegal organ donation racket involving Bangladeshi nationals. Similar cases had surfaced in Tamil Nadu and other states involving locals and crime networks that spread across India, Nepal, Afghanistan and more.
What India’s transplant law permits and prohibits
In 1994, the Government of India enacted the Transplantation of Human Organs Act. The aim was to regulate the removal, storage and transplantation of human organs for medical treatment while preventing commercial exploitation. On 8th July 1994, the then-President of India gave assent to the law. In 2011, the law underwent major changes through an amendment, which came into effect in January 2014.
The amended legislation became known as the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, or THOTA. Furthermore, the government also notified the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Rules on 27th March 2014, which established detailed requirements linked to consent, medical evaluation, transplantation approval, hospital registration and documentation.
What Indian law permits and prohibits
Section 3 of the Act deals with the authority for removing human organs and tissues. Section 9 deals with the restrictions on living-donor transplantation. Section 10 regulates hospitals, and Section 12 requires medical practitioners to explain the possible effects, complications and hazards of organ removal and transplantation to donors and recipients.
Section 19 of the Act specifically deals with commercial organ transactions. According to it, making and receiving payments for supplying human organs is prohibited. Furthermore, finding people willing to supply organs for money, negotiating commercial arrangements and participating in organisations involved in such dealings are also illegal under the Act. It also covers specific activities that involve the creation of fake documents intended to establish a donor-recipient relationship or claim that a donation is being made because of affection or attachment.
Notably, not every payment linked to an organ transplant is illegal. There are charges that need to be paid to hospitals, including those for medical tests, surgery, hospitalisation and other services, which are legal transactions. Such payments are excluded from the Act. Furthermore, the Act also excludes certain permissible expenses and losses directly linked to donation from its definition of payment.
Therefore, paying a hospital for a kidney transplantation procedure is legally different from paying an intermediary to procure a person willing to “donate” a kidney in exchange for monetary benefits. In the latter situation, the transaction would fall within the prohibition under Section 19 of the Act.
The legislation also establishes the powers of authorities who are responsible for registering hospitals, investigating complaints and taking action against violations. There are separate provisions prescribed under the Act that list the punishments for unauthorised organ removal and commercial dealings.
Who can legally donate an organ while alive?
In India, living organ donation is primarily associated with donations between family members. However, the law also recognises certain arrangements which involve people who are not related.
According to THOTA, near relatives, including spouses, parents, children, brothers, sisters, grandparents and grandchildren, can become living donors for recipients within the family. A person who falls into this category may donate an organ to an eligible relative. However, even in these cases, consent, medical evaluation and verification procedures are a must and should be completed before the transplantation procedure.
If two persons are near relatives, it does not automatically make one person suitable for donating a living organ to another. Doctors must examine the prospective donor’s health to determine if the procedure can be performed safely and ensure that the person understands the possible medical complications following the procedure.
Who can legally donate an organ in India?
According to the 2014 Rules, hospitals and the responsible authorities are required to establish the relationship through appropriate documents. These may include birth certificates, family records, marriage certificates, photographs and other recognised evidence based on the relationship between the donor and the recipient.
Furthermore, Indian law also permits a person to donate an organ to someone outside the near-relative category because of affection, attachment or another special reason. However, Section 9(3) of THOTA states that prior approval from an Authorisation Committee is needed before such transplantation.
For instance, a person may want to voluntarily donate a kidney to a close friend who needs transplantation. While the law does not prohibit such a donation just because they are unrelated, a committee has to examine their relationship, reasons for the offer and whether any prohibited financial arrangements exist.
The law also permits arrangements such as paired or swap transplantation. Such an arrangement is considered when two patients have willing near-relative donors, but they are not biologically compatible with their intended recipients. If the donors are compatible with the other patient, Section 9(3A) of THOTA allows transplantation across the two pairs. Notably, permissions and approvals are required as per the law in such conditions as well, and they could be even more stringent.
Minors are not permitted to be living donors except on exceptional medical grounds. Under Rule 5(3)(g), such donations require detailed medical justification and prior approval from the Appropriate Authority and the concerned State Government.
How does the authorisation committee examine a donation?
Transplantation applications are required to undergo additional approval under THOTA by an Authorisation Committee, particularly when living donors are not near relatives of the recipients.
This committee is different from the Appropriate Authority that is responsible for hospital registration, inspections and enforcement. While doctors determine if transplantation is medically suitable, it is the duty of the committee to examine if the proposed donation meets the legal requirements.
According to Rule 11 of the 2014 Rules, in such cases, State-level Authorisation Committees and additional committees at district or hospital level may be constituted. If a transplant centre is performing 25 or more transplants every year, it is required to have a hospital-based committee. Those hospitals that perform fewer than 25 transplantations generally rely on State or district-level committees.
The rules do not allow members of the operating transplant team to serve on the committee examining the relevant application, separating the legal approval process from the medical team’s decision to perform the surgery.
Under Rule 7, the committee is bound to examine the relationship between the donor and recipient for unrelated living donations. The committee examines how they came to know each other, why the donor wants to undergo surgery and if there is an intermediary involved in the decision.
Furthermore, the committee also examines the financial circumstances of the donor. The rules require consideration of occupation and income during the preceding three financial years, along with any substantial difference in financial position. Such a difference does not automatically establish wrongdoing. However, it may require closer examination.
For example, if a financially distressed person is offering a kidney to someone without any established relationship, the committee must examine the explanation for the donation and the evidence supporting it.
The rules require the prospective donor to be interviewed by the committee. Under Rule 21, such an interview must be video-recorded and minutes maintained. Additional precautions apply in the case of women donors, including independent confirmation of their identity and consent. If required, the committee can also obtain the views of the donor’s near relatives or other qualifying adult relatives.
The committee is required to record reasons for approving or rejecting an application. Under Section 9(6) of the Act, the committee is bound to give a reasoned decision when an application is rejected after giving the applicants an opportunity to be heard. The law also provides an option for appeals against the decision made by the committee.
Urgent medical circumstances may require faster consideration, but they do not remove the requirements concerning eligibility, consent and approval.
How are donor-recipient relationships verified?
The verification process depends on the relationship claimed by the donor and recipient and may differ from case to case. Under Rule 18, relevant birth certificates, family records and identity documents are checked in the case of genetically related donors. In case the available evidence does not conclusively establish the relationship, the responsible authority may need to conduct additional verification, which can include DNA profiling.
Notably, not all transplant applications require DNA testing. It may be required in cases where documentary evidence is not enough to establish the claimed genetic relationship.
In the case of spouses, the authorities may examine evidence of marriage, which includes marriage certificates, photographs and relevant family details. The duration and circumstances of the marriage may also be considered.
How an Authorisation Committee examines a donation
In the case of unrelated donations, authorities are required to examine the personal connection between the donor and recipient. The committee may seek older photographs, records of previous contact or other evidence that supports the reason given for donation.
Provisions under Rule 14 are applied in cases where verification is required for an unrelated donor or recipient who belongs to another state or Union Territory. The prescribed residential verification must be obtained from the appropriate official.
When the committee finds the documents to be incomplete or doubtful, it may seek clarification or verification from the issuing authority. While a discrepancy does not automatically establish deliberate forgery, the additional information provided by the donor and recipient must clear the doubts before the application can be properly assessed and moved forward.
These checks are essential because a certificate may appear genuine without actually having been issued by the authority named on it. Similarly, an authentic identity document cannot independently establish that someone is donating voluntarily or that no prohibited payment is involved.
When poverty becomes part of the illegal kidney trade
A mix of poverty, debt and illegal kidney trade in India is not a new phenomenon. According to a report published by OpIndia in January 2023, there are villages in some parts of the country that are known as “kidney villages”, where financially distressed people had historically been approached by organ brokers.
The report talked about Bharathi Nagar in Villivakkam, Chennai, which has acquired names such as Kidney Nagar and Kidneyvakkam because of illegal kidney trade activities. It also referred to the towns of Pallipalayam and Kumarapalayam in Tamil Nadu, where poor residents were targeted by organ brokers for decades.
In 2002, a study was published in the Journal of the American Medical Association that examined the economic consequences of illegal kidney trade in Chennai. 305 people who had sold a kidney were questioned. On average, the participants had sold their kidneys six years before the interviews took place in February 2001.
Did selling kidneys help people escape poverty?
The aim of the study was to determine if the money received had improved their financial circumstances and what health issues they reportedly faced post-surgery. According to the study, 96%, or 292 out of 305 participants, stated that the reason behind selling the kidney was to repay debts. Among those, 74%, or 216 people, were still in debt at the time of the interview.
The researchers also found that they were not paid the amount that was promised before the surgery. On average, they were promised a payment of $1,410, but they received an average payment of around $1,070.
Most of the participants stated that the money was spent on existing debts, food, clothing and other household expenses. Furthermore, the average family income had declined by one-third after the kidney was sold, and the proportion of participants living below the poverty line had increased.
86% of the participants reported deterioration in their health. Notably, the health issues faced by those who participated in illegal organ trade should not be seen as a benchmark for legal organ donors.
This study holds significance because it questioned if selling a kidney had provided lasting financial relief. For many participants, the payments made in exchange for the kidney were spent on immediate expenses without resolving the financial difficulties that actually led to the sale of an organ.
It has been over two decades since the study was conducted. However, financial distress is still a prominent reason for illegal organ trade and often appears in police investigations concerning such commercial organ transactions. There have been several reported cases where large sums were offered to those struggling with debt, unemployment and other financial problems.
How intermediaries become involved in illegal transplantation
During investigations into organ trafficking, investigators have found that several people perform different roles in such trades. Some accused persons may be involved in identifying prospective donors, while others connect them with recipients, arrange travel, handle paperwork or facilitate hospital appointments.
Medical tourism companies and patient assistance services may legitimately provide some of these services. While their involvement may not be unlawful, some intermediaries have also been implicated in illegal organ transactions. The legal problem arises when an intermediary arranges a prohibited financial transaction, participates in deception or helps obtain transplantation through fraudulent documents.
In April 2024, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) issued notices to the government of Haryana and Rajasthan after taking notice of reports linked to an organ trafficking network. Media reports from that time stated that the network was spread across international borders.
According to the NHRC, Haryana health officials had conducted a raid at a hotel in Sector 39, Gurugram. They reportedly recovered a Bangladeshi national whose kidney was removed at a hospital in Jaipur in exchange for monetary benefits. Four other people who had reportedly undergone kidney transplantations were also found.
The Commission sought reports from the governments concerning the allegations and steps taken to prevent illegal organ trading. The case shed light on how transplantation investigations may extend beyond the hospital where surgery took place. Travel arrangements, accommodation, intermediaries and records concerning donors and recipients can all become relevant when police suspect commercial transactions.
When false documents enter the approval process
When it comes to organ transplantation applications, they may contain identity records, family documents, affidavits, medical reports and certificates meant to establish a donor’s eligibility. There have been allegations that in illegal organ trading, these records are often forged or manipulated to create apparently legitimate relationships between donors and recipients.
During the investigation into such a case in Kerala, the police stated that documents were prepared or altered at Sun Communication DTP Centre and Sign HD Digital Studio in Ernakulam. According to the prosecution, photographs were edited and certificates were prepared using forged letterheads and seals to support applications submitted for transplantation approval.
Investigators examined whether the documents had actually been issued by the authorities named on them. Statements from government officials and people whose identities appeared in the files were compared with the records recovered during the police search.
In a similar case in Delhi, police stated that forged identity documents and relationship records were used in transplantation applications involving foreign nationals.
During investigations, once it is established that the documents were forged or manipulated, investigators have to establish who prepared the disputed material, how it was submitted and whether those involved knew that the documents were fake.
Foreign recipients and India’s transplantation rules
According to Indian law concerning transplantation, foreign nationals are permitted to undergo such procedures in India, subject to the legal requirements applicable to their circumstances.
Rules 19 and 20 of the 2014 Rules deal with such cases and prescribe additional checks for living-donor transplantation involving foreign nationals. Such applications need approval from an Authorisation Committee even if the donor and recipient are near relatives. The relationship between the two must be certified through Form 21 by a senior official of the concerned country’s embassy. In case the country does not have an embassy in India, the prescribed certification must be obtained from its government.
The rules also prohibit transplantation from a living Indian donor to a foreign recipient who is not a near relative. Applications involving an Indian donor and a foreign near-relative recipient require careful examination.
These requirements received renewed attention in April 2024 when Director General of Health Services Dr Atul Goel issued directions to states and Union Territories concerning suspected commercial organ dealings involving foreign nationals.
The Centre asked authorities to investigate suspected violations, inspect registered transplant hospitals and ensure that information concerning transplantation procedures was submitted to the national registry. The government also sought closer monitoring of foreign-national cases.
Cross-border trafficking can also involve Indian nationals travelling abroad to supply organs. In a reply submitted by the Government of India on 9th December 2025, the Ministry of Home Affairs confirmed that the National Investigation Agency (NIA) had registered a case on 3rd July 2024 involving five identified victims who travelled from India to Iran on tourist visas and underwent transplantation in Tehran.
According to the ministry, the victims had been attracted by promises of financial benefits. A chargesheet had been filed against four arrested accused persons, while further investigation was continuing when the reply was submitted.
Indian investigations involving alleged organ trafficking
Kerala, 2026: Forgery, financial transactions and medical tourism
The Kerala investigation centred on allegations that Kallatharas Medical Tourism Pvt Ltd had facilitated commercial kidney transplantation through intermediaries and fraudulent documents.
The Enforcement Directorate stated that the network had operated between 2021 and 2026. The prosecution material examined by the Kerala High Court referred to suspected activities from August 2023 onwards in the particular police case before it.
According to the High Court’s order, the police examined statements from several donors and recipients after recovering transplantation files and allegedly forged documents.
A donor identified as Shibulal reportedly stated that the accused had handled the paperwork connected with his transplantation. He said that he was given Rs 10 lakh before surgery, but the money was immediately taken back and later returned after deductions towards paperwork.
Another recipient, Abdul Latheef, reportedly told investigators that he had become acquainted with Najeeb while visiting Lakeshore Hospital. According to his statement, Najeeb offered to arrange a kidney transplantation and informed him that Rs 12 lakh would be required towards documentation, obtaining a donor’s consent and related expenses.
The police also questioned Dr Dhanya, a medical officer at the Family Health Centre in Kumarapuram, Ernakulam district. She reportedly stated that an attestation appearing in a transplantation file did not carry her genuine signature or seal.
The investigation involved comparing hospital and committee documents with statements from donors, recipients and officials. Police sought to establish whether false relationships had been presented to obtain approval and whether money had been paid in connection with supplying kidneys.
The ED subsequently examined suspected financial transactions, bank accounts and properties associated with the accused. Its June 2026 release stated that freezing orders had been issued concerning bank accounts linked to agents and intermediaries.
Najeeb denied wrongdoing, while the Kerala High Court refused bail after examining the material available at that stage. The verified order did not determine his guilt following a completed trial.
Kanpur, 2026: How a Rs 50,000 dispute exposed an alleged kidney racket
A dispute over Rs 50,000 brought attention to a suspected illegal kidney transplantation network in Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh, in March 2026.
In a report published on 1st April 2026,OpIndia reported that a prospective donor named Ayush, an MBA student living in Meerut, had allegedly agreed to sell a kidney for Rs 10 lakh because of financial difficulties. According to the account, he received Rs 9.5 lakh and complained about the remaining Rs 50,000.
The dispute was reported as an important development in the exposure of the alleged network. The FIR accessed by OpIndia, however, described a police team receiving information about suspected illegal transplantation at Ahuja Hospital while checking suspicious people and vehicles near Maswanpur crossing.
The distinction is important to the chronology. The reported payment dispute and the information recorded in the FIR formed part of the accounts surrounding the investigation, but they should not be treated as identical descriptions of how the police first received information.
According to the FIR details published by OpIndia, police were told that doctors from outside the hospital were performing transplantation procedures on people brought there through financial inducement. The informant also claimed that an operation was taking place at the hospital.
Senior officers were informed, and a police team accompanied by medical officials reached the premises. The team encountered ambulance operator Shivam Agrawal, who was suspected of arranging donors and recipients, and questioned hospital operators Dr Surjeet Ahuja and Dr Preeti Ahuja.
The FIR reportedly recorded that the hospital’s CCTV cameras were not functioning. Police alleged that the cameras had been deliberately switched off during unauthorised transplantation procedures.
Investigators also recovered cartons containing medicines and equipment associated with transplantation. According to OpIndia’s account of the FIR, the donor, Ayush Kumar, and recipient, Parul Tomar, were traced to separate hospitals, where medical officers reportedly confirmed that both had undergone kidney surgery.
Police suspected that transplantation procedures were carried out at one facility before donors and recipients were moved elsewhere for postoperative care. The investigation involved Ahuja Hospital, Med Life Hospital and Priya Hospital and Trauma Centre.
The initial investigation resulted in six arrests, including five doctors and an ambulance operator. Police alleged that medical professionals and intermediaries had arranged transplantation procedures without complying with the required legal process.
According to the FIR details reported by OpIndia, a surgical team had been brought from outside to conduct operations. Investigators also examined allegations that doctors were approached to perform procedures at night and that hospital facilities were used in exchange for money.
The amounts reportedly paid by recipients were considerably higher than the payments offered to donors. Contemporary reports cited figures ranging from several dozen lakh rupees to more than Rs 90 lakh in connection with suspected transactions. These were investigative allegations concerning different arrangements, not an established uniform price for every transplant. The case continued to develop after the first arrests.
In a report published on 2nd July 2026, Hindustan Times stated that Kanpur Police had filed an approximately 1,000-page chargesheet against 14 accused persons.
Deputy Commissioner of Police SM Qasim Abidi said the chargesheet was supported by CCTV footage, bank transaction records, phone recordings, WhatsApp conversations and other documentary evidence. Police named 40 prosecution witnesses, including the alleged donor and recipient.
The accused named in the reported chargesheet included hospital operators, medical personnel, an alleged intermediary and others suspected of facilitating transplantation. Police also stated that five accused persons remained absconding at the time.
Investigators examined allegations involving another hospital, Ramashiv Hospital in Swaroop Nagar, but found no corroborating evidence linking it to the suspected transplantation procedures. Neither the hospital nor its management was named in the chargesheet, according to the report.
The case subsequently reached the Allahabad High Court. In an order dated 15th July 2026, Justice Krishan Pahal granted bail to Akhilesh Tiwari, an accused in Case Crime No. 121 of 2026 registered at Rawatpur Police Station under THOTA and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.
Tiwari argued that he was an employee at the hospital and was not qualified to perform transplantation surgery. The court granted bail after considering the submissions and material placed before it, without expressing an opinion on the merits of the case.
The Kanpur investigation involved allegations extending beyond false documentation. Police examined whether unauthorised transplantation procedures had been performed through private hospitals, how donors and recipients were brought together and whether the people involved knowingly participated in the alleged transactions.
The chargesheet placed the police allegations before the court, but the criminal responsibility of individual accused persons remained subject to trial.
Delhi, 2024: The Bangladesh-linked kidney transplantation investigation
In Delhi, a suspected kidney trafficking network involving Bangladeshi nationals came under investigation in June 2024.
The Crime Branch registered FIR No. 124/2024 after receiving information about alleged commercial kidney transplantation involving financially vulnerable donors and forged documents.
In a report published on 30th August 2024, OpIndia stated that Delhi Police had filed a 7,112-page chargesheet naming ten accused persons, including three Bangladeshi nationals identified as Rasel, Muhammad Sumon Miyan and Mohammad Rokon, who was also known by other names.
According to the police account, the alleged network approached patients requiring kidney transplantation and arranged prospective donors through intermediaries.
Investigators reportedly recovered forged identity records, stamps and transplantation-related documents. The allegations concerned procedures involving Bangladeshi nationals during the period from 2021 to 2023.
Transplant surgeon Dr Vijaya Rajakumari was among the people arrested during the investigation. Police alleged that she was connected with transplantation procedures arranged through the suspected network and had knowledge of certain irregularities. Her counsel denied the allegations and maintained that she had performed surgery only after the prescribed approvals had been obtained.
The dispute reached the Delhi High Court in August 2024. In its order dated 23rd August 2024, the court recorded that the relevant kidney transplantation had received approval from an Authorisation Committee through Form 18. Documents had also been authenticated by the concerned embassy through Form 21.
Justice Amit Mahajan noted that the prosecution had not alleged that Dr Rajakumari personally prepared the disputed documents or served on the committee responsible for approving the transplantation.
The court granted her bail with conditions after considering the material available at that stage. It also made clear that its observations should not influence the criminal trial.
The proceedings continued after the bail order. On 30th September 2026, the Delhi High Court modified Dr Rajakumari’s bail conditions to permit her to travel to Ethiopia for employment after examining a verified job offer and imposing conditions intended to secure her attendance during the criminal proceedings.
The Delhi investigation raised questions about the accuracy of documents submitted for transplantation approval and the responsibility of medical professionals who performed procedures after those approvals were obtained.
Even where a committee has approved transplantation, investigators may subsequently question whether the information submitted was genuine. However, the knowledge and conduct of each accused person must be established separately.
Tamil Nadu, 2025–2026: Kidney trafficking allegations and hospital regulation
The kidney trafficking controversy in Namakkal district brought the attention of Tamil Nadu authorities to allegations that financially distressed people had been induced to supply kidneys for payment.
During 2025, the state initiated regulatory action concerning transplantation permissions at Dhanalakshmi Srinivasan Medical College and Hospital in Perambalur and Cether Hospital in Tiruchirappalli.
The allegations led to government inquiries and criminal investigations. Dhanalakshmi Srinivasan Medical College and Hospital subsequently challenged the cancellation of its transplant registration before the Madras High Court.
Four recent Indian organ trafficking investigations
According to the court’s order dated 14th November 2025, the hospital’s registration had been temporarily suspended on 23rd July 2025. A subsequent order dated 18th August 2025 cancelled the registration.
The hospital argued that the authorities had acted without issuing the notice and providing the opportunity to respond required under Section 16 of THOTA. It also disputed the allegations concerning its transplantation activities.
Justice M Dhandapani examined the cancellation order and found that the prescribed notice and hearing requirements had not been followed. The court therefore set aside the order while allowing the authorities to proceed afresh in accordance with law.
The court did not decide whether the hospital had been involved in illegal organ trading. Its judgment concerned the procedure followed before cancelling the registration.
Meanwhile, a Special Investigation Team continued examining the suspected kidney trafficking incidents.
On 23rd February 2026, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court recorded that the SIT had investigated three cases and proceeded against 12 accused persons.
According to the report submitted to the court, final reports in all three cases had been presented through electronic filing before the Judicial Magistrate at Kumarapalayam on 17th February 2026.
The court closed a petition seeking transfer of the investigation to the CBI after considering the SIT’s progress.
What responsibilities do hospitals and doctors have?
According to Section 10 of THOTA, if a hospital wants to conduct organ transplantation, it must have the relevant registration. Sections 14 and 16 of THOTA govern hospital registration and the circumstances in which permission may be suspended or cancelled.
The law requires hospitals to maintain qualified personnel, suitable facilities, medical records and documentation required for transplantation approval. Furthermore, hospitals must ensure that donor and recipient assessments are completed before surgery takes place.
The surgeons who would be conducting the transplantation operation are responsible for medical decisions concerning the procedure. However, an Authorisation Committee may intervene and independently examine the legal conditions governing the donation in case its approval is required.
Hospital administrators, transplant coordinators and staff handling documentation may also have responsibilities concerning applications, records and compliance with the approval process.
It is the responsibility of the police to establish who prepared and submitted documents in case they are found to be forged or manipulated. Also, the police must identify the persons involved in the process and determine whether they were aware that the documents were false.
The presence of a forged certificate in a hospital file does not automatically establish deliberate participation by every medical professional connected with the surgery. Similarly, the fact that a hospital conducted a transplantation later questioned by police does not by itself establish institutional criminal liability.
Section 16 of THOTA allows the Appropriate Authority to suspend or cancel the registration of a hospital as per the law in case it is found to have indulged in illegal organ trade. Section 17 of THOTA provides remedies to hospitals through appeals against specific decisions.
In case medical professionals are found to have indulged in illegal organ trade, they may face disciplinary action under the applicable medical regulatory framework along with the legal consequences.
How do police investigate suspected organ trafficking?
Police proceedings begin with a complaint from a donor or recipient, information received by police, suspicious financial transactions or irregularities discovered in hospital records. During the investigation, state police, health regulators, Special Investigation Teams (SITs) and central agencies, including the CBI, the ED and other agencies, may initiate investigations either in collaboration with each other or independently, based on the circumstances and legal jurisdictions.
Investigators may obtain and examine transplantation applications, identity documents, Authorisation Committee decisions, medical records, bank statements and electronic communications. Witness statements help establish how donors and recipients were introduced and whether money was offered or paid.
For instance, during the investigation into illegal organ trade in Kanpur, police examined hospital procedures, financial payments, electronic messages and the circumstances in which surgery was performed. In the case of the investigation into illegal organ trade in Kerala, police examined whether the documents were forged, examined financial records and took statements from persons named in transplantation files.
Where the conduct involves trafficking for organ removal, provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, including Section 143 where applicable, may be invoked alongside THOTA. Depending on when the offences occurred, provisions of the earlier Indian Penal Code may also apply.
Following an investigation, police may file a chargesheet or final report before the competent court, after which the evidence is examined through the judicial process.
What punishments does Indian law provide?
THOTA prescribes substantial penalties for unauthorised organ removal and commercial transactions.
Under Section 18, unauthorised removal of a human organ in the circumstances covered by the provision may attract imprisonment extending to ten years and a fine extending to Rs 20 lakh.
Section 19 provides imprisonment of five to ten years and a fine ranging from Rs 20 lakh to Rs 1 crore for commercial dealings in human organs.
Penalties under India’s transplant law
Section 19A separately deals with illegal commercial dealings in human tissues, prescribing imprisonment of one to three years and fines ranging from Rs 5 lakh to Rs 25 lakh.
Other provisions address violations of the Act under Section 20, offences involving companies and the circumstances under which courts may take up cases under the legislation.
The punishment imposed in an individual case depends on the offences proved and the court’s final findings. The maximum sentence prescribed by law does not mean that every accused person receives it.
How much of India’s illegal organ trade is officially recorded?
India maintains a national transplant registry, but comparable figures on illegal organ transactions, prosecutions and convictions remain difficult to obtain.
In a Lok Sabha reply dated 26th July 2024, the Union Health Ministry was asked for state-wise figures on illegal organ trade cases registered during the preceding five years and their conviction rates.
The ministry stated that the relevant data was not maintained centrally. It explained that state governments and Union Territory administrations were primarily responsible for implementing the law and investigating suspected violations. A separate dataset was provided by the Ministry of Home Affairs in December 2025.
According to National Crime Records Bureau figures cited in the parliamentary reply, the number of victims recorded as trafficked for organ removal and rescued was four in 2019, none in 2020, six in 2021, 17 in 2022 and five in 2023.
These figures represent rescued victims in a particular reporting category. They do not establish the total number of people trafficked for organ removal or the number of illegal transplantation procedures performed in India.
The available data also does not provide a reliable basis for concluding whether organ trafficking is increasing or decreasing. Changes in recorded numbers may reflect differences in detection, investigation, reporting or actual criminal activity.
A separate problem concerns the completeness of information submitted by registered hospitals. In a government release dated 10th March 2026, the Union Health Ministry stated that 217 of the 804 registered hospitals performing organ transplantation had failed to report data to the National Registry Portal during 2025.
The ministry said regulatory action against the hospitals concerned was the responsibility of state governments. Failure to report transplantation data does not establish involvement in illegal organ trading. However, incomplete records make it more difficult to monitor transplantation activity and assess whether hospitals are meeting their reporting obligations.
How does NOTTO help authorities monitor transplantation?
Authorised hospitals submit information concerning donors, recipients and transplantation procedures. These records help authorities establish where and when procedures were performed and which institutions were involved.
The central government’s April 2024 directions required hospitals to generate unique NOTTO identification numbers for donors and recipients in all transplantation cases. In living-donor transplantation, the identification number was to be generated at the earliest, within a maximum of 48 hours after surgery.
The Centre also called for regular hospital inspections and monthly sharing of transplantation data. A registry entry cannot independently establish that a donation was voluntary or that the supporting documents were genuine. Those matters depend on the approval process and further investigation where irregularities are suspected.
State Appropriate Authorities remain responsible for hospital registration, inspections and enforcement. Their records, together with information maintained by NOTTO, are important for monitoring the transplantation system.
What happens to people exploited by organ trafficking networks?
People recruited into illegal organ transactions may face medical, financial and legal difficulties after surgery. Living kidney donation requires medical evaluation, informed consent and appropriate follow-up. Even where a person is medically suitable, recovery from surgery may affect employment and daily activities for a period.
For someone who agrees to supply a kidney because of financial hardship, the promised payment may also become a source of dispute. Historical research in Chennai found that many kidney sellers remained in debt despite receiving money.
Recent investigations have involved similar allegations concerning payments promised to prospective donors. Investigators must also distinguish between people accused of organising illegal transactions and those whose participation may have resulted from coercion, deception or exploitation.
Affected individuals may require medical care, legal assistance and access to relevant victim-support services. Their willingness to participate in criminal proceedings may also depend on appropriate protection.
How are regulators responding to suspected illegal transplantation?
The Union government has directed states and Union Territories to examine suspected commercial organ dealings, monitor transplantation involving foreign nationals and conduct regular inspections of registered hospitals.
Recent investigations have also involved state health authorities, police and financial investigators examining alleged violations.
However, the available national records do not establish how many inspections resulted in confirmed violations, how many hospital registrations were suspended or cancelled, or how many decisions were subsequently modified or overturned.
Without comparable figures, it is difficult to assess whether enforcement is consistent across states or whether measures introduced following major investigations have produced lasting improvements.
Why preventing organ trafficking requires more than prosecution
Criminal investigations are necessary when there is evidence of illegal organ dealing, but prevention also depends on the functioning of the legitimate transplantation system.
Patients require access to authorised hospitals and suitable donors, while prospective living donors need reliable medical information, appropriate counselling and protection against coercion.
Expanding deceased organ donation may improve access to transplantation for eligible patients. However, increasing the availability of organs cannot by itself prevent deliberate forgery, unlawful financial transactions or exploitation.
According to NOTTO Annual Report 2025–26, released on 3rd August 2026, India recorded 20,138 organ transplants in 2025. The ministry also reported that 89,839 people were on the major-organ waiting list as of 3rd March 2026, based on information submitted to the national registry.
The figures indicate substantial transplantation activity alongside continuing demand. They must also be considered with the reporting gaps disclosed by the ministry.
Improving lawful access to transplantation, maintaining reliable approval procedures and protecting donors are connected responsibilities.
What should India prioritise next?
India already has legislation governing consent, donor-recipient relationships, transplantation approval, hospital registration, inspection and punishment for commercial organ dealings. The main question is how consistently these requirements are implemented.
Authorisation Committees must maintain reliable records of applications, interviews, supporting documents and decisions. Hospitals must submit complete transplantation information to the national registry, while state authorities must investigate suspected violations and follow the legal requirements governing regulatory action.
Comparable national figures on investigations, chargesheets, convictions, acquittals and hospital action would make it easier to assess enforcement. Such reporting should distinguish allegations from completed judicial proceedings and protect sensitive information concerning donors and recipients.
Greater transplantation capacity must be supported by oversight that can identify unlawful conduct without unnecessarily obstructing legitimate donation.
From donor to recipient, the system depends on trust
The investigation into illegal organ trade in Kerala began with suspected forged documents and transplantation files recovered during a police search. It subsequently developed into a case involving financial investigators, statements from donors and recipients, and proceedings before the Kerala High Court.
In Kanpur, a payment dispute brought attention to suspected commercial transplantation involving private hospitals, medical professionals and intermediaries. Police subsequently filed a chargesheet against 14 accused persons. The Delhi investigation raised questions about allegedly forged donor-recipient relationships and the responsibility of doctors performing approved transplantation procedures, while the Tamil Nadu proceedings demonstrated the importance of following the law when taking regulatory action against hospitals.
India’s transplantation system involves a series of medical and administrative decisions long before a patient reaches the operating theatre. Doctors assess suitability, families make decisions about donation, hospitals maintain records and authorities examine applications requiring approval.
The work of these professionals and institutions has helped expand transplantation in India. At the same time, the investigations examined here show why the circumstances surrounding organ procurement require careful scrutiny.
An organ may be medically compatible with a recipient, but the law also requires that it be obtained through a legitimate process. In living donation, that means valid consent, proper verification and freedom from prohibited commercial arrangements.
For patients awaiting transplantation, the availability of an organ may determine whether they receive the treatment they need. For living donors, the decision may involve undergoing major surgery to help another person. Both depend on a system in which medical decisions are properly assessed, donations are genuinely voluntary and those attempting to exploit the process are held accountable through the courts.
Anurag has over 22 years of professional experience, including more than six years in journalism. He is known for deep dive, research driven reporting on national security, terrorism cases, judiciary and governance, backed by RTIs, court records and on-ground evidence. He also writes hard hitting op-eds that challenge distorted narratives. Beyond investigations, he explores history, fiction and visual storytelling. Email: [email protected]
From an IAF heart transfer between Delhi and Pune to a Vande Bharat journey, hospitals rely on preservation methods, green corridors and coordinated transport services to get donated organs to patients in time for transplantation.
Brain-stem death must be certified before families can authorise donation. Doctors then assess organs, coordinators find suitable recipients and retrieval teams work against time, with strict legal rules governing every stage of the donation process
From finding a suitable donor to hospital registration and organ allocation, patients face medical, financial and geographical barriers. Unequal access, incomplete reporting and lifelong treatment make transplantation far more complicated than surgery alone for families.
The toll of the weather is being recorded, but how much compensation is actually reaching farmers, labourers and affected families? Are we more focused on relief than risk reduction?
Valued at up to ₹50 lakh per kilogram, genuine Indian oud oil is a formidable global luxury asset. This investigative deep dive explores how artificial inoculation, aggressive state subsidies, and the authorisation of direct air cargo exports from Guwahati are transforming Assam’s traditional agarwood sector into a highly formalised, multi-billion rupee agricultural powerhouse.
The first Dalit-Muslim political partnership was not born in Lucknow. It was born in Bengal, more than 75 years ago. It involved the most important Dalit leader in Indian History.