Let’s start with a story from 1977. Fresh elections were conducted in India with the Janta Party government coming to power and George Fernandes, a socialist stalwart, taking over as Minister of Industries. Foreign exchange regulation act of 1974 had diluted the foreign ownership to 40 percent. So accordingly Fernandes instructed Coca-Cola to strictly adhere to the law and on top of it allegedly he wanted Coca-Cola to share the products secret formula. Coca-Cola agreed to abide by the law but declined the secret formula request. According to the company, that was a ‘trade secret’. As a result the company left India which was followed by IBM. A new domestic substitute was launched and promoted by the government called ‘Double Seven’.
That same year Parle came up with its own cola, ‘Thums Up’, which captured the markets. Coca-Cola made a return in 1993 after the Indian economy threw open its doors and interestingly bought Thums Up and other drinks for approx $60 million. Thumbs Up brand value crossed the billion dollar status in 2021! New Delhi wanted the secret formula from Atlanta but vice-versa happened.
Why am I telling all this? Because this is just a preview for a bigger picture. We can easily divide the history of trade secrets in 3 points.
The first point deals with India getting the benefit of stealing. We start with ‘Tea’ where a Scottish plant hunter named Robert Fortune in 1848 slipped 20,000 tea plants from China with the know-how to cultivate them, and brought them for the the East India Company. The British yolk stole another country’s secret and built an entire industry on our land. The Hindu in 2013 reported after reading Edward Snowden’s document that India was placed 5th when it came to American surveillance.
In the second point India takes the legal path. Before independence we had Indian patents and design act 1911 which got replaced by The Patents Act 1970. The act granted patents for the ‘manufacturing’ of medicines, not medicines per se. The result? Indian chemists did reverse engineering by studying foreign drugs and figuring out their own ways to make them, making India the ‘pharmacy of the developing world’.
Last point starts from 1990 where we became keepers. At present India has over 2100 global capability centres(GCC), places where foreign companies do their research, engineering and analysis, employing over 2 million people. Total revenue from these GCC was estimated to be $98.4 billion in 2025-26. An illustration of India being trusted by foreign companies.
The journey from asking for secrets to keeping them is indeed a persuading story as India climbs the ladder to become a developed country by 2047. An important key for it to happen is the ‘trade secrets law’ which is missing. We only have small latches and locks here and there when it comes to trade secrets. This article argues why it is the right time for India to get its own Trade Secrets Act.
This month, the world witnessed something surreal. The CEO of the world’s most coveted chip company was having an affair with a Chinese woman who allegedly is a Chinese spy. The story didn’t stop here, it further spilt more beans about another affair with the company’s vice president, which resulted in the resignation of the CEO of Nvidia, Jensen Huang.


Nvidia holds the largest share of the chips market when it comes to global AI and Data Center graphics processing units(GPU), approx 80 percent. Jensen Huang, co-founder and former CEO, is undoubtedly one of the best brains of the 21st century. The New York Times in October reported that US intelligence officials believed a former Chinese executive of a Singapore based data center company, Megaspeed, was recruited by Beijing and was linked to Jensen Huang. They believed that the woman was gathering information about him and using her magical influence for expediting chip sales to China. Interestingly Megaspeed had become one of Nvidia’s largest customers by buying about $4.8 billion worth of its equipment.
On November 8th Jensen accepted being unfaithful to his wife and apologised to the staff. In the last hours of being a CEO it is reported of him saying, “I’m a piece of s**t.”
An independent investigation was started by Nvidia’s board with outside lawyers to find out if indeed he was the target of a foreign spy agency. Though the company believes that neither its own proprietary information nor national security was compromised. Anyone’s private life shouldn’t be judged. The story is changing by the hour, as Jensen might be brought back as CEO, and even to this point it’s unclear if any sensitive information was leaked to Beijing.
The company shares went downhill by 4.3 percent and wiped $190 billion of its value in a single day, 9th of November to be precise. A class action suit was filed by one of its shareholders in California accusing that investors were misled. US lawmakers asked Jensen to testify before Congress on 18th November. Amongst all this chaos the first question which came to almost everyone’s mind was, ‘Were the company’s secrets safe’?
Firstly the server wasn’t hacked, it was an alleged relationship. Breaking the lock isn’t necessary if one can woo the person itself who’s having the key to the lock. Secondly the question asked, ‘What was taken’? Nvidia says that their proprietary information wasn’t compromised which may be true but what intrigues me is that how can any company say this so surely? To be this sure one needs to know what secrets are there, who had access and what exactly a theft of those secrets would look like. These all are questions which a trade secret law would ask the companies and help them prove. Without them, doubt itself would become the cost to pay.
Thirdly if the allegations are on a foreign state then the theft altogether becomes different. India’s law commission has already argued about this as the Official Secrets Act of 1923 deals only with political spying and government secrets. The Act is a misfit when it comes to economic or corporate espionage.
Lastly we imagine this scenario in Bengaluru as Nvidia has design centers in Pune, Hyderabad and Bengaluru. Let’s say a top level executive, founder or even an engineer from an Indian chip design company or the Indian arm of a foreign company is suspected of passing information to rivals, and the board wants to act. Which law will it turn to? The IT Act if a computer was involved. Contract law if the contract was drafted well by applying the evergreen doctrine of breach of confidence. We don’t have a law that defines trade secrets or even associated terms with it. The core argument I make is that we need a trade secret law and we need it urgently. A developing country on track of being a developed one needs to be trusted by multinational companies to keep their secrets safe.
David Cohen’s essay in Foreign Affairs is the reason why I wanted to write this. He argues in that essay why America should drop its long-standing notion of not spying on foreign companies to help its own.
A plain explanation of his arguments is that America has always refused to use spycraft to give American companies an upper hand. This rule was turned into a presidential directive by Barack Obama in 2014. Cohen recounts that once a CIA officer had told the then Director Robert Gates bluntly that he was willing to sacrifice his life for the country but never for a company. Further Cohen makes his point that this notion can’t be applied in contemporary times as the technologies that decide national power, from AI chips to batteries, are coming from private companies. The line between company and country has vanished. China has already taken the lead in critical technology. He says America is turning the field against itself by holding back. Though he agrees that by lifting the ban there’ll be a risk of spy race, distortion, favouritism, and corruption.
The drift has already started. In early September, CIA Deputy Director Michael Ellis told a cybersecurity conference that Chinese firms working in AI, chips and biotechnology could be treated as legitimate targets. Beijing replied sharply, saying that it would act under its own counter-espionage law.
There are two points in Cohen’s essay which matter to India far more than the spying itself.
The first is the warning. Cohen points out that under the present American rule the government can already tell an AI company that foreign spies are after its model weights, since that is considered security and not commerce. He calls such warnings necessary but not enough. A warning means little unless the firm has something it can do next, and in India a firm which learns that its secret is being stolen has no clear law to run to.
The second is the shield. America can afford to argue about building a sword because it already owns a shield. Its Economic Espionage Act of 1996 makes stealing trade secrets a federal crime, and a graver one if the theft is meant to help a foreign government. Since 2016 the Defend Trade Secrets Act has also allowed owners to sue in federal court, and the House passed it by 410 votes to 2. Then in January a San Francisco jury convicted a former Google engineer on seven counts of economic espionage and seven counts of trade-secret theft. He had taken over 2,000 pages about Google’s AI computing systems for the benefit of China, and US officials called it the first conviction of its kind for AI-related economic espionage. So America is debating the sword with a shield already in hand, while India is yet to forge its shield.
Let me explain a trade secret in simple words, as everything turns on it.
A trade secret is any business information which is valuable because it is secret, and which its owner takes reasonable steps to keep that way. It can be a formula, a manufacturing process, a customer list, the code of a program or the trained ‘weights’ of an AI model, which are simply the numbers that make it work. The Law Commission’s report defines it in just this way, as information that is not generally known, valuable because it is secret and guarded by reasonable steps.
Compare it with a patent. A patent is a deal with the public where you explain your invention to the world, and in return the state gives you a monopoly for a fixed period. A trade secret is a deal with the law, where you tell no one and the law promises to punish anyone who takes your secret by improper means. The protection can last for as long as the secret stays safe.
It is equally important to see what the law doesn’t do. It doesn’t stop anyone from working out the secret on their own, and it doesn’t stop a rival from buying your product and taking it apart to see how it works. Those are honest ways of learning and they stay lawful. The law forbids only theft, bribery, breach of trust and knowingly using what was stolen. So a trade-secrets law is a fence and not a monopoly, a point which the Law Commission made itself by saying that trade secrets shouldn’t be treated like property with exclusive rights.
This matters for India because our strongest industries run on know-how, like making a drug cheaply or delivering software at scale. Company everywhere also lean on secrecy much more than on patents. Another Cohen, the economist Wesley Cohen, along with Richard Nelson and John Walsh, asked 1,478 American research labs how they protect their inventions. In most industries, patents came near the bottom of the list while secrecy and lead time were near the top, and interestingly, pharmaceuticals were the main exception.
The world agreed a long time ago that secrets deserve a legal shield. Article 39 of the TRIPS Agreement, which is a World Trade Organization rule, requires its members to protect undisclosed information. India has signed it, yet the rule hasn’t produced a law so far.

America isn’t alone in this. The European Union in 2016 adopted a Directive which gave every member state the same basic rules against the unlawful taking, use and sharing of trade secrets, and it set June 2018 as the deadline for national laws.
India is different. A recent analysis by the law firm King, Stubb & Kasiva says that India is one of the major economies without a dedicated trade-secrets law. There is no law which defines a trade secret, no specific claim for taking one and no set of remedies. So what do Indian firms do? They stitch. Judges have built a working framework out of contract law, the old doctrine of breach of confidence, copyright in some cases, the rules on injunctions and, depending on the facts, criminal and cyber laws. The same analysis adds that the protection has to be put together from several bodies of law which were never designed for this job.
Start with contracts. Firms use confidentiality clauses, but Section 27 of the Contract Act voids agreements which restrain a person’s trade, and in Superintendence Co. v. Krishan Murgai the Supreme Court held that a restraint after the employment had ended was unenforceable. Then comes judge made law, where courts have drawn a line between the general skill of a worker and the secrets of an employer, and in exceptional cases they have even granted search and seizure style orders. And then crime. Section 316 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita covers criminal breach of trust and the IT Act covers unauthorised access to computers, but whether they fit a given case depends on the facts.
To be fair this is no small thing, and good judges and good lawyers have undoubtedly kept the lights on. But a patchwork has three weaknesses. Firstly every case starts from zero, because with no definition in the statute book each plaintiff must first persuade a court about what a trade secret even is. Secondly a patchwork rewards the well-lawyered. A multinational can draft airtight contracts and hire teams to enforce them, whereas a five-person start-up or a family workshop can’t. Thirdly it fits criminal law badly, as the rules written for stolen goods and breached trust sit awkwardly on a file copied to a personal account.
In April the US Trade Representative again kept India on its Priority Watch List and said that India lacks a dedicated trade-secrets law. India’s own position is that existing remedies work and that international rules don’t demand a standalone law. That position is arguable. But the American list also contains demands on medicine patents and test data which many Indians of every party resist. So here is the sovereign answer. We shouldn’t refuse a right thing just because a foreign power asked for it first, and neither should we do it as a favour to anyone. The law should be written for our own reasons and on our own terms.
India has asked for this law again and again and has not yet written it. The science ministry in 2008 released a draft National Innovation Act which was meant to set out the law of confidentiality and trade secrets, with a chapter on confidential information. It never reached Parliament. In 2016 India and the United States said in a joint statement that they would work on trade-secret protection, and the National IPR Policy took note of it. The government’s own legal departments in 2017 asked the Law Commission to study a trade-secrets act and an economic-espionage act. A parliamentary committee reviewing the IPR regime in 2021 said in its 161st report that India needed a separate trade-secrets law. In March 2024 the Law Commission delivered its report along with a draft bill of 13 sections, also asking for a second and separate law on economic espionage. As of 20th October, a legal tracker reports, no such bill had been introduced in Parliament.
Look at that list once more. A ministry asked, a parliamentary committee asked, the Law Commission asked and so did our trade partners. The asking has gone across governments of different parties, so there is nobody to be blamed. The draft is ready. Parliament has also shown that it can legislate for the digital age, as the data protection law which protects the personal data of citizens had its rules notified in November 2025. A law for the secrets of firms is its natural partner.
Setting aside the Nvidia story I see 4 reasons for doing this now.
The first reason is the vault. Coming back to those 2000+ GCCs, what India quietly exports through them is trust. Khaitan & Co, a leading Indian law firm, notes that foreign investors see the lack of effective protection for business secrets as a significant concern. It takes years to build trust and only a single leak to lose it. So if a secret leaks from any one of these centres India should have a clear law ready to address it, and not a hunt through six different bodies of law.
The second is the homecoming. Our best start-ups are coming back home. When PhonePe returned from Singapore its investors paid approx ₹8,000 crore in tax, close to a billion dollars! Razorpay was expected to pay about $150 million. We celebrate this homecoming and we should. But there is an irony in it. A start-up with an American parent can reach for America’s federal trade-secrets law where its secret relates to a product or service used in interstate or foreign commerce. Once the parent is brought home though, all it can count on here is the patchwork. Lawyers will argue about how much protection a flipped company really loses. Still a country which asks founders to come home shouldn’t hand them a weaker shield when they arrive.
The third is the weights. In the age of AI the crown jewel isn’t a drawing or a recipe, and Cohen’s own example is the secret weights of a model. A trained model is in the end a very large file of numbers, which its owners guard mostly by keeping it secret. India’s AI mission says that it has onboarded more than 38,000 GPUs for start-ups and researchers. If India’s first big AI models are to be Indian in fact and not just in name their weights will need the protection of law, and so will every Indian company which trains on a client’s data.
The fourth reason is that we have already promised. The UK-India trade agreement came into force on 15th July and its intellectual property chapter has a section on trade secrets. It asks both countries to give legal means against taking, using or sharing confidential information contrary to honest commercial practice, including when a third party gets it through gross carelessness. Reverse engineering, independent discovery and whistleblowing are treated as legitimate in it, and it also asks for confidentiality protections in court such as closed hearings and edited judgments. The EU-India agreement, concluded in January, has provisions on secret information too. Though the government says that it requires no change to Indian law. India may well keep these promises through judges alone, but then it is luck that guards it.
The law also cuts both ways as Indian firms face it abroad. A Wisconsin jury in 2016 awarded Epic Systems $940 million against Tata Consultancy Services(TCS), an amount which was cut to $280 million after appeals, and TCS has said that it believes there was no misuse. In a second case involving TCS in 2023, a Texas jury awarded Computer Sciences Corporation $210 million. Whatever the merits, Indian firms need clear rules about what they may use as much as about what they may keep. Self-reliance isn’t only about making things at home, it is also about keeping what we know.

Going back to the Nvidia story for a moment, what strikes me the most is how old it is. The route alleged was a person.
The philosopher Michael Polanyi observed that we know more than we can say. A master potter, a chef, a process chemist or a loom-setter, each of them carries a skill which no manual fully captures, and according to him such knowledge passes mostly through apprenticeship, by watching a master and practising under guidance. The economist Friedrich Hayek made a related point, that the most useful knowledge in an economy is local, scattered and often unwritten, held by the people on the spot.
India is a civilisation of apprenticeship. The guru and the shishya, the ustad and his pupils, the family recipe and the master weaver were all systems which moved secrets from hand to hand under trust, and in such systems it was kinship and reputation that did much of the work which law does today. This works as long as the workshop is a village. It can’t work when the workshop is a campus and the apprentices are 2.36 million people who change jobs. Custom doesn’t scale and as a result law has to take its place.
Kautilya knew that secrets leak from the inside. Book 1 of the Arthashastra has a whole chapter on how to keep a king’s plans from escaping. Sanskrit writers from Manu to Kautilya warned that even parrots and starlings can betray a council, and Jolly’s notes on the Arthashastra recall a tale from Banabhatta’s Harshacharita in which a king loses his kingdom because a parrot overheard his secret council. The parrot was inside the room. It is the same today, from the Google engineer in California to India’s 2015 leak case where the police alleged that confidential government papers were sold to corporate buyers. A trade-secrets law must therefore speak first to insiders, that is employees, vendors, executives and officials, and also to the habits of the firms which guard against them.

One last thing. Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras list asteya, non-stealing, amongst the basic restraints (the yamas) and promise that when it is firmly established all jewels present themselves. A vow is a private act whereas a law is how a community makes that vow public and gives it teeth. A country which is known for keeping other people’s secrets will always have customers.
So what should the law say? Most of the work is already done, as the Law Commission’s draft is a good start, and I will point out where I would add to it.
Firstly it should say what a trade secret is, which is information that isn’t generally known, that is valuable because it is secret and that its owner has taken reasonable steps to protect. The draft says this by following the world trade rule, and I would keep it narrow.
Secondly it should say what theft is, that is taking a secret by improper means, using or sharing it in breach of a duty and knowingly using what someone else stole. The draft covers this too.
Thirdly, it should keep honest discovery free. A rival who works out the secret on its own, or who buys your product and takes it apart, is within the law and the draft says so. I would add one plain sentence stating that the Act creates no monopoly and no special right over test data. That protects the tradition of generic medicines, and it also answers the fear that this law is a Trojan horse for foreign drug companies.
The fourth point is about whistleblowers, journalists and the public, who should be protected. The draft says that disclosures made to expose wrongdoing, or in good faith for the public interest, are not theft, and the Commission’s report itself discusses press freedom. I would say plainly that honest reporting is covered.
Fifth, it should keep the worker free. Section 27 stays, the Act creates no new non-compete and the general skill and experience of a worker belong to the worker.
Sixth, the owners should get real remedies in a real court. That means injunctions and damages in commercial courts as the draft proposes, along with fast interim relief because a secret that is out can’t be put back.
Seventh, it should keep the courtroom quiet. India has already promised the UK protective orders, closed hearings and edited judgments, and without them a plaintiff would have to reveal the secret in order to prove it.
Eighth, the burden should be scaled to the size of the owner, so that ‘reasonable steps’ for a start-up doesn’t mean the vault of a bank.
Ninth, there should be an emergency valve, but one with a clock on it. The draft lets the Central Government compel licensing in a national emergency or extreme urgency, which Khaitan notes is unusual. I would keep this, but define what an ‘emergency’ is, require fair terms and a time limit and allow a court to review it. It is the Indian answer to an old question which the Mahabharata calls apad-dharma, the rules for hard times. The emergency should be named, the exception limited and the day it ends written down, with Parliament reviewing the whole Act after 5 years.
Tenth, state-backed theft should get its own law as the Commission recommended. A case like the Nvidia one, if it were ever proved, is exactly what such a law is for. America has a separate and graver offence for it and India should have one too, narrow and carefully fenced as the stakes for the accused are huge.

A law on secrets has to bind the state just as it binds the citizen.
Interestingly Parliament has already used the phrase ‘trade secrets’. Under Section 8(1)(d) of the Right to Information Act, information including trade secrets is exempt from disclosure when it would harm the competitive position of a third party, unless the larger public interest requires otherwise. So the law shields trade secrets from the curious citizen, but it hasn’t yet been written to punish the thief.
The State is also one of the biggest keepers of other people’s secrets, be it drug approvals, tenders, tax records or regulatory filings. Further, the Act should give officials a clear duty to protect whatever firms hand over, with clear penalties for those who leak it. A state which wants founders to trust it must show that it can keep a secret.
It must also resist the old temptation, as we saw in 1977 when a minister asked for a recipe. That temptation hasn’t gone away. Reuters in January reported that draft smartphone security rules would require makers to let government designated labs review their source code, and that Apple and Samsung had objected behind the scenes. India’s IT ministry said that it refuted the report and was not seeking source code. I don’t know who is right and I take the government at its word. But look at the shape of the argument. A real public purpose, which is security, meets a request for the crown jewels of a firm. A trade-secrets law should settle such questions in advance, like when the state may ask to see a secret, who may see it, under what promise of confidence and what happens if it leaks. We should write the answers down so that to make the trust and security hold.
The espionage law needs the strongest safeguards of all because it is where the sharpest tool of the state lies. Recall the Nambi Narayanan case. In 1994 he was leading ISRO’s cryogenic engine work when he was jailed on a spy charge. The Supreme Court later awarded him ₹50 lakh for having been wrongly arrested and harassed, and in 2021 it ordered the CBI to probe the officers behind the case. A state which can cry ‘spy’ without proof can break its best minds. And we have just seen in America how quickly an allegation can move markets before any court has spoken. So prosecutions for economic espionage should need senior sanction and judicial oversight, with consequences for false accusations.

There is one more lesson from our history. In the eighteenth century a trading company, the East India Company, grew into a private army of approx 2,60,000 men and conquered the subcontinent. The state should be the keeper of secrets and never their broker, which means that no secret entrusted to the state should ever be passed to a favoured company.
A reply which ignores its critics is just a pamphlet, so let me take up the 5 hardest questions I know of.
The first objection is that existing law is enough, and the government’s view does have force. Courts have protected confidential information for decades and the law firm analysis I cited says plainly that no statute doesn’t mean no protection. My answer is yes, and that is exactly the point. The protection exists but it has to be assembled from laws which were never written for it, case by case, at a cost the small can’t bear. The Law Commission, a parliamentary committee, the legal departments of the government itself and our trade partners have all concluded that a statute is better.
The second is that this will help foreign drug companies and hurt access to medicines. It is the deepest fear on the left and history does give it weight. My answer is that a trade-secrets law protects secrets and not monopolies. Reverse engineering and independent discovery stay lawful, which is exactly how the generic industry of India was built, and the draft carries an emergency valve for public health. The Act should also say plainly that it grants no exclusive right in test data. The debate on medicine patents should be fought on its own ground and not smuggled in through this door.
Then there are those who say that this will chain workers. For them my answer is that Section 27 stays, the Act adds no new non-compete, the general skill of a worker stays with the worker and whistleblowers are protected.
Another objection is that espionage laws get abused, and the case of Nambi Narayanan undoubtedly proves it. My answer is that the civil Trade Secrets Act and the criminal Economic Espionage Act should be kept separate. The first protects firms from rivals and carries no prison terms, whereas the second reaches only theft for a foreign state and needs senior sanction, judicial oversight and consequences for false accusations.
The last one is that laws don’t stop spies. That is true as a statute won’t stop a determined state. America and China pledged in 2015 not to steal commercial secrets by cyber means, and the decline in incidents was reversed within a year. Promises in words change like the weather, but a lock is built into the architecture. And a lock does raise the cost of theft, most thieves are insiders and rivals whom the law can reach, and a country can complain credibly about theft only if its own statute book condemns it.
What makes this reform rare is that the market liberal, the nationalist and the welfare minded can each support it for different reasons. The first wants property and contracts to be respected, the second wants Indian knowledge to stay Indian and the third wants the small fish protected.
Back to 1977 then. India asked the world’s most famous company for its secret and the company answered by leaving. In 2026 the world is asking India to keep its secrets and the answer has been to arrive, with 2,117 centres, 2.36 million people and $98.4 billion a year. The trust is indeed real, though it rests on contracts, courts, goodwill and a dozen latches, and not yet on a lock.
The world watched, in Jensen Huang’s case, what happens when the secrets of a company are in doubt. A giant lost approx $190 billion in a day before anyone had proved a thing. I don’t know how that story will end, but I do know that doubt is expensive, and that in the long run the cure for doubt is clear law, which every country wanting to be trusted with the next generation of technology will have to offer.
The next recipes won’t be colas. They will be chip designs, drug processes and the weights of India’s first big AI models. Some of them will be Indian secrets and some will be the world’s, left in our care. The cola we built in Coke’s absence was later bought by Coke. So let the next formulas stay Indian by choice and not by luck, and let the foreign ones stay safe here by law and not by courtesy.
Cohen asks whether America should build a sword. For India there is a prior question, have we built the lock?
A secret without a law is only a hope, and it is time we gave the hopes of India the force of law.

While India has mastered coastal cyclone and tsunami mitigation, the 2026 Global Status of Multi-Hazard Early Warning Systems Report highlights critical telemetry deficits in the Himalayas. Discover why disaster management must transition from reactive relief to anticipatory action.

A Rs 50,000 payment dispute in Kanpur, suspected forged transplant documents in Kerala and a Bangladesh-linked investigation in Delhi have raised questions about donor protection, hospital approvals and the enforcement of India’s organ transplantation laws.

The toll of the weather is being recorded, but how much compensation is actually reaching farmers, labourers and affected families? Are we more focused on relief than risk reduction?
Selected issues, clear explanations and thoughtful perspectives—delivered when we publish.